Skip to content

There was no Pregnancy Pact – Pregnant Gloucester Teen Speaks Out

June 24, 2008

Last week, TIME magazine reported on an alleged “pregnancy pact” made by teens at Gloucester High School, with school principal Joseph Sullivan claiming that “some girls seemed more upset when they weren’t pregnant than when they were” and indicating “early half the expecting students, none older than 16, confessed to making a pact to get pregnant and raise their babies together.”

Yesterday, it was reported that there may not have been a pregnancy pact at all, and that the principal is “foggy” in his memory of how he heard such a thing in the first place. You know, because when there are 17 pregnant teens (4 times the usual number) in a 1,200-student high school and you hear that they formed a “pact” to become pregnant, that’s totally forgettable.

Seriously, what better way to proclaim that a lack of proper sex ed or lack of contraceptive availability has no bearing on these pregnancies than to suggest that the girls were sneakily and deliberately trying to become pregnant? These pregnancies have been blamed on Jamie Lynn Spears, the movie Juno, and the “fashion trend” of Hollywood babies, further removing responsibility to these girls from the local community.

Some commenters suggested that the presence of a day care at the school encouraged these girls to become pregnant, which I find to be just another form of “slut shaming” – it’s as though these folks believe, “You don’t deserve to finish your high school education, because you had teh sex.” (See this previous post for my take on school day care centers and education for pregnant teens) I think we can be reasonably certain that the natural sexual urges of teenagers had a lot more to do with their getting pregnant than some feeling that they weren’t properly taking advantage of the school day care.

Keep in mind that the principal also claimed that “The community won’t tolerate access to birth control at the high school.” The students receive some sex ed in middle school and their first year of high school, but it is an abstinence-based program. A nurse-practioner for the high school stated that “Kids have identified that there’s not easy, confidential reproductive health care in Gloucester.” According to reports, “two officials at the high school health center resigned to protest the local hospital’s refusal to distribute contraceptives through the school without parental consent.”

This completely ignores the reality that “nationwide, 47.8% of [high school] students had ever had sexual intercourse,” there are clearly barriers in place in this community for teens who want to be sexually responsible.

Others have referred to Gloucester as a “fishing town,” assuming that girls may not be as motivated to prevent pregnancy when there are few apparent options available to them for their futures. Again, this community responsibility goes unaddressed in favor of speculation about how pacts and Juno may have glamorized teen pregnancy.

Finally, one of the teens from Gloucester has spoken out, through an appearance on Good Morning America. Seventeen-year-old Lindsey Oliver, who reports having been on birth control when her unplanned pregnancy occurred, says:

“There was definitely no pact. There was a group of girls already pregnant that decided they were going to help each other to finish school and raise their kids together. I think it was just a coincidence.”

Ms. Oliver was also asked whether distribution of birth control at the school (which she believes officials have erred in not providing). She smartly replied: “The kids are obviously having it anyway; there are 17 pregnant girls.” Ms. Oliver may very well be smarter than her principal on this matter.

It remains to be seen whether the rise in pregnancies at Gloucester High School is merely a statistical blip – the rate of pregnancy at the school still does not represent an alarming deviation from national norms. A look at recent CDC reports suggests that births to teens have risen in recent years, but provides an incomplete picture of teen pregnancy in the United States. Meanwhile, we can continue to provide abstinence-only education and put in barriers to contraceptive use, while blaming pop culture for teenage pregnancies, or we can look at how our communities and policies may be failing young people. One of these is easy (and doesn’t seem to improve anything), and one is hard. Which will the people of Gloucester, MA choose? What will you?

Related Links:
Sisterhood of the Maternity Pants
Inconsistent Contraception Use
But Juno!
OMG Pregnancy Pacts!!?!?!
Google blog search

[I should note that it will be interesting to hear from the other girls, and whether they confirm the notion that there was no pact.]

9 Comments leave one →
  1. June 24, 2008 2:28 pm

    Not directly related, but you might want to include a link to Mags’s conversations with pre-teens, like this one:

    The ignorance about birth control, sex, and their own bodies is heartbreaking.

  2. June 24, 2008 2:39 pm

    nm, you’re absolutely right – reading Mags’s posts on these conversations often makes me very sad. Everybody else, go over there and browse around for the relevant posts.

  3. June 24, 2008 4:15 pm

    Thanks for the link, nm and Rachel. The stories are, indeed, heartbreaking… and they keep mounting. Right now, the big issues are cutting and violence, but there’s certainly all the sex stuff too.

    One of the girls that I usually talk to, but who had stopped coming for a while, told me that she had needed a condom for a project and that she’d asked around the boys for one, and most of them wouldn’t give her one, but the one that did said that he’d only give it to her if she went up to the deserted third floor and showed him her breasts. She did, he tried to feel her up, she kicked him in the balls and went back downstairs.

    I informed her that if she needed another one, she could come to me, and I gave her a condom right there on the spot.

    Even with me handing out condoms and advice, it seems like my girls are exactly the kind of kids who would be caught up in this sort of manufactured scandal. As it is, I’m surprised more of our kids haven’t turned up pregnant. *sighs*

  4. Meghan permalink
    June 25, 2008 5:06 pm

    I wish that those girls had seen that new Baby Borrowers show on NBC. Maybe that would have had an impact.

  5. Kellie permalink
    June 25, 2008 5:09 pm

    I”m been hearing a ton about that show. I wonder if it’ll be any good.

  6. Jamie permalink
    June 25, 2008 5:17 pm

    Yeah, the previews look good. It premieres tonight I think.

  7. Malice permalink
    June 25, 2008 6:36 pm

    Teenagers need to realize how long an obligation a child is. There is a lot involved in the raising of kids. Just watch an episode of Baby Borrowers to see what kind of challenges these teens endure. Lots.

  8. Spears permalink
    July 10, 2008 3:54 am

    Jamie Lynn Spears’ syndrome? The media has glamorized her unwed teen pregnancy. Teens think it is cool.


  1. Damned if You Do; Damned if You Don’t « Tiny Cat Pants

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: